Book Review: Widow Barnaby by Fanny Trollope

Widow Barnaby
Fanny Trollope
From what I understand, Fanny Trollope made Widow Barnaby into something of a franchise. The widow, who is a bit of an archetype of the brash, sometimes vulgar, and always clueless social climber, apparently features in other of Mrs. Trollope’s novels (although sitting here in jury duty right now, I can’t really confirm that). I assume it is for this reason alone that the novel is actually called Widow Barnaby. In sentiment, sympathy, and even narrative focus the novel would more aptly be called Agnes Willoughby after our anti-heroine’s orphaned niece. In these two characters we have the classic set-up between the wicked, controlling aunt and the virtuous, obedient niece. Throw in a pious, spinster of a great aunt, a few pretenders and charlatans and more than one possibile Mr. D’Arcys and you start to get the feel of this particular story.

There are very few instances in this 542-page book where one feels even a pang of sympathy for the extravagant Widow Barnaby and her clumsy machinations to marry her way into higher society and live beyond her means. Of course the converse is true of the beautiful, level-headed and studious Agnes who has the singing voice of an angel. As much as I enjoyed the book, it is a little hard to understand while you are reading it why Trollope made Widow Barnaby the focus of the book. She is definitely a humorous character at times and one can understand how her travails could provide fodder for multiple books, but the whole arc of the story so clearly focuses on Agnes that I kept checking the cover to see if the title had somehow changed. And the widow is not so fantastically humorous and wicked that one starts rooting for her despite her nefarious ways. It would take a far more cynical mind than my own to turn against the lovely Agnes.

Which brings up another question: would it have been too much of a stretch to ask for an ugly heroine? Or maybe one without talent? I mean this Agnes really is the total package. You know she is going to come up smelling of roses. Still, there are enough twists and turns to keep one wondering just what is going to happen. And, at least for my taste, Agnes and her virtues never become cloying or annoying.  Just don’t expect this one to challenge your world view.

Not having previously read anything by the great Anthony Trollope’s mother I wasn’t sure what to expect. One area where Mrs. Trollope does not disappoint and certainly foreshadows some of her son’s work is in her seemingly endless references to money. If there are two themes in period British literature that I can’t get enough of, it is housekeeping details (this includes cleaning, trousseau-gathering, travel arrangements, letter writing, tea making and consuming, etc.) and money talk. He has 400 a year, she has 5,000 a year, he has 15,000 a year…bills to be paid, fortunes to be amassed and spent and bequeathed. I must admit though I much prefer the parsimonious over the profligate. In life and art I like the savers over the spenders.

7 thoughts on “Book Review: Widow Barnaby by Fanny Trollope

  1. Hannah Stoneham June 9, 2010 / 12:35 pm

    I would quite like to try this as I like Anthony T… although it does sound that this Agnes is one of those characters who is a little too perfect!

    Lovely review as usual,



  2. Danielle June 9, 2010 / 1:57 pm

    I've never read Trollope before–mother or son. Actually I didn't realize she also wrote, though I have several of his books on hand. Heroines usually aren't unattractive, are they? Have you tried any books by Mary Webb? She wrote one called Precious Bane (published by Virago) where the heroine has a harelip–and it's even a bit of a love story. I really liked it, though will mention it was one of the books that Stella Gibbons parodied in her Cold Comfort Farm (of those doom and gloom books of the Victorians).


  3. Amanda June 9, 2010 / 3:34 pm

    I didn't even know that Anthony Trollope's mother was a writer! Now I've got two Trollope authors to read!


  4. Thomas at My Porch June 11, 2010 / 8:47 am

    Hannah: I just imagined I was Agnes and that all good things eventually would come my way.

    Danielle: You know I have never read Cold Comfort Farm and when I saw the film adaptation of it back in the 90s (?) I wasn't expecting a parody so I never quite got into it. I am going to have to revisit that one.

    Amanda: As far as Trollope's go, start with The Warden, the first in Anthony's Barchester series. I don't think you will be disappointed.


  5. mary June 11, 2010 / 6:18 pm

    Hmmm … I'm an old cynic, Thomas. I thought Agnes was a bit of a drip and I was definitely rooting for the Widow, who is absolutely the heroine as far as I'm concerned … My guess is that Fanny T sympathised with her, too, and imbued her with some of her own indefatigable spirit. And I was glad that she landed on her feet in Australia!


  6. Thomas at My Porch June 15, 2010 / 10:13 pm

    Mary: I can understand your feelings about Agnes. But I just found the widow's heart to always be in the wrong place I had a hard time giving two figs for her survival. She reminded me of all those snotty, uncouth females that Jane Austen inserts into her movies, uhh…, I mean novels.


  7. silverseason February 9, 2012 / 8:47 am

    The book is about the Widow and not Agnes because the Widow is the energy of the book. Agnes is a conventional, good looking, talented and virtuous heroine and you know that she is going to come all right. With the Widow, who can say! Also, she is the reverse side of the matter-of-factness about money. She knows what she has, and she wants more, not accepting the place in life assigned to her.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.