Book Review: Old Books in the Old World

Old Books in the Old World: Reminiscences of Book Buying Abroad
Leona Rostenberg & Madeleine B. Stern

Imagine transatlantic crossings on the Holland America Line, spending a month and half each summer digging through antiquarian books in the capitals and countryside of Europe, buying hundreds of old books to ship back to the United States to resell for a profit. My own interests in books do not run to the antiquarian side of things, but given the chance I would gladly immerse myself in such excursions. Leona Rostenberg and Madeleine Stern were business partners, friends, and companions for 60 years. Beginning in 1942 the pair became partners in their rare book firm in New York and spent a chunk of their summers traveling to Europe to buy stock. Both were Columbia University educated literary scholars, and considered themselves literary sleuths. In addition to writing five books on the antiquarian book trade, their achievements include a major discovery about Louisa May Alcott. The following passage is taken from a wonderful tribute to Stern at

Miss Stern was enormously proud of the fact that she and her dear friend, business partner, and companion “literary sleuth,” Leona Rostenberg, helped bring to light Louisa May Alcott’s unknown tales of intrigue, murder, adultery, suicide — and as Miss Stern put it, “thuggism, feminism, hashish, and transvestitism” to boot.

“One of our greatest thrills,” Miss Stern wrote in 1997, “was our discovery of the double literary life of America’s best-loved writer of juvenile fiction. The revelation that the author of Little Women was also the author of clandestine sensational shockers was our blood-and-thunder story.”

The reminiscences in Old Books in the Old World are taken from Rostenberg and Stern’s diary entries from their book buying trips to Europe between 1947 to 1957. After most entries the authors include retrospective epilogues that provide perspective on their experiences as well as dishing the details on where some of their book finds ended up and how much they sold them for.

I love books of all kinds. But the world of antiquarian books is one that I doubt I will ever enter so I don’t know much about it. Old Books in the Old World gives a wonderful glimpse of what goes on in that world. These are seriously old books on seriously old topics. Sixteenth and Seventeenth century manuscripts, books, pamphlets and other ephemera on politics, science, history, geography, religion, philosophy and other topics written in English, French, German, Italian, Dutch, and other languages. Rostenberg and Stern knew what they were doing but often bought things on a hunch, not really knowing what they had in their hands until they get it back to the U.S. to study it and figure out where it fit into the antiquarian universe.

Until I read Old Books in the Old World I never really wondered where universities and libraries got their rare book collections. Not the ancient universities of Europe, those probably grew organically over hundreds of years, but some of the more “recent” universities in the New World like Yale, Columbia, and Cornell. And institutions like the Newberry, Folger, and Library of Congress. And in some cases, books that they bought and overseas and shipped back to New York were eventually sent back across the Atlantic where they found homes at places like the British Museum and the University of Basel.

Besides the tales of treasure hunting for good deals and great books (which of us aren’t drawn to that?), Rostenberg and Stern also give a fantastic firsthand account of post-war Europe. Traveling through England, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium, Italy, and Austria they provide many details of everyday life that are so often missing from World War II histories. I knew about rationing and food shortages in Britain following the war but didn’t realize that a piece of bread could be considered one of the courses in a three course meal at even the nicer restaurants in London. Or another instance where Rostenberg refuses to sit at a table of Germans at an antiquarian conference in Austria. It is hard to imagine what those relationships would have been like so soon after the liberation of the Nazi death camps. Throughout their travels between 1947 and 1957 the duo also heard firsthand accounts of how some of their bookseller friends, Jewish and otherwise managed to survive the war. And with each bookbuying trip they see improvements as England and Europe eventually return to normalcy. They also see the prices of books rise as antiquarian treasures become harder and harder to find.

Old Books in the Old World would be great for anyone with even a passing interest in the antiquarian book trade or for someone interested in a little post-war social history or gossipy European travelogue.

8 thoughts on “Book Review: Old Books in the Old World

  1. Book Psmith November 8, 2009 / 7:46 pm

    Thank you for directing me to this book…I loved reading Old Books, Rare Friends and Bookends earlier this year but did not know about this one.


  2. Thomas November 9, 2009 / 12:45 am

    Book Psmith: I had purchased two of their other books when I was at Powell's Books in Portland, OR a few years ago. But we had the store ship our huge pile of books and the package never arrived. We got a refund, but that wasn't as good as getting the fabulous books we found.


  3. verbivore November 9, 2009 / 3:08 am

    This sounds like a lovely book, especially since, like you, I don't have much knowledge of antiquarian books (although when I was still living in the US I loved visiting The Atheneums in both Boston and Providence, which have loads of old books to browse through). But I can imagine how wonderful those book-buying trips must have been.


  4. Jeane November 9, 2009 / 9:38 am

    I don't know much about antiquarian books, but any book about book-hunting would intrigue me.


  5. Citizen Reader November 9, 2009 / 11:47 am

    I was born at the way wrong time. Ebooks and Kindles are just not as cool, and never will be, as BOOKS.

    I must get this book immediately. Thanks so much for the review.


  6. Citizen Reader November 9, 2009 / 11:48 am

    And…I see in your sidebar that you just read “The Bookshop.” What did you think?? I've been dying to find people to chat that one over with.


  7. Nan November 9, 2009 / 12:01 pm

    I wonder if you have read Helene Hanff's 84, Charing Cross Road. This book gives such a sense of the 'old days' of book buying. I've read it several times and each time am amazed.


  8. Thomas November 10, 2009 / 8:25 pm

    Verbivore: Thanks for stopping by. I don't know the Anteneums in Boston and Providence, I will have to check them out.

    Jeane: It was fun to book hunt vicariously with the authors.

    Citizen Reader: I often feel like I was born at the wrong time as well. But if I went back in time I would have to also magically do away with car exhaust, smoking everywhere, and homophobia. But I will never Kindle, there are enough books in print. Worse comes to worst I will just read what is already on the planet.

    Nan: I have read 84 CCR. It is one of my favorite books and one of my favorite movies. And there are elements of this book that remind me of Marks and Co. In fact they write about going to “Marks” but I don't know if it is the same thing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.